llm-wiki-newsroom: Command for Claude Code

/wiki-lint sub-procedure — Contradiction Theme Mapping (full re-derivation)

Not a slash command — a sub-procedure of /wiki-lint, reached from contradiction theme --fix. Invoking it directly runs nothing.

This guide prescribes the procedure for reading all claims in _contradictions.json and generating _contradictions_themes.json (the theme ↔ claim mapping SoT). Since the output is structured JSON, not markdown prose, journalism · consulting form does not apply (unlike overview authoring). Schema conformance · contradiction-axis accuracy · self-validation are the core.

A Claude with no prior knowledge must be able to read this guide alone and reproduce the same quality · structure.

Read before working:

• wiki-lint.md → ## Sub-procedure: Conflict Axis Sync Rule (SoT hierarchy · cross-assignment principle)
• wiki/contradictions/_contradictions.json (main input — all claims; for structure see "Input Data Structure" below)
• For Phase 2 only, wiki/contradictions/_contradictions_themes.json (carrying over the Phase 1 output)
• As needed, wiki/sources/<slug>.md (source originals — Phase 2 Priority Read targets; for structure see "Source File Structure" below)

---

Input Data Structure

_contradictions.json — Main Input

The top level is a JSON array, and each element is a record with the fields below. python tools/build.py contradictions auto-generates it by extracting - contradicts: [[Hub]] — desc lines from the ## Connections section of source pages.

{
  "id": "a709b575",
  "source": "sources/agentic-ai-kill-saas-debate.md",
  "claim": "[[osi-open-source-ai-definition]] requires training-data disclosure, whereas this document argues that releasing open weights alone is sufficient to count as open.",
  "status": "open",
  "type": "real",
  "type_score": 0.6,
  "evidence_strength": 0.42
}

Field	Meaning	Use in theme derivation
id	First 8 chars of the SHA1 hash of the claim text. The key referenced by claim_ids in _contradictions_themes.json	Must use this value verbatim
source	Path of the Layer 2-1 source file this claim was extracted from (sources/<slug>.md)	The actual Read target during Priority Source Read
claim	The desc part of the ## Connections - contradicts: [[Hub]] — desc line (after the prefix is removed). The contradiction is summarized in 1–2 sentences	The primary basis for judging the contradiction axis
status	Currently fixed at "open"	Unused
type	Auto-classification result — one of 4 values real · superseded · related · soft (explained below)	Priority-Read selection · auxiliary grouping judgment
type_score	Type-category keyword-match score 0.0–1.0 (sum of regex weights capped at 1.0)	Lower = weaker classification signal (re-classification candidate)
evidence_strength	Phase 2 meta-based evidence strength 0.0–1.0 — anchor presence 0.30 + source recency 0.15 + ratio of ## Key Claims primary sources 0.40 + target hub type 0.15	Higher = strong contradiction (priority ## Representative Evidence candidate). Lower = weak signal (consider drop)