red-blue-review

RED BLUE REVIEW — Adversarial Attack/Defense with Scoring

Red breaks. Blue fixes. Red re-attacks. Points decide.

Target: $0 (default: staged changes) Scope: $1 (default: full | full|security|api|performance)

---

SCORING

Event	Red	Blue
Valid critical finding	+10	—
Valid high finding	+5	—
Valid medium finding	+2	—
Invalid/false finding	-5	—
Fix verified (no bypass)	—	+5
Fix bypassed by Red	+3	-3
Test case accepted	—	+2

---

TEAM ARCHITECTURE

REVIEW LEAD (You — Orchestrator)
│
│  TeamCreate: "red-blue-review"
│
├─ Phase 1: RED ATTACK (3 teammates, coordinate via SendMessage)
│  ├── red-crash-hunter ──────┐
│  ├── red-security-attacker ─┼── SendMessage: share attack vectors
│  └── red-api-breaker ───────┘   TaskCreate: each finding → shared list
│  └── GATE → validate findings, shutdown_request → Red
│
├─ Phase 2: BLUE DEFENSE (1 teammate per MODULE)
│  └── blue-defender-N ── TaskUpdate: claim findings, SendMessage: cross-module fixes
│  └── GATE → fixes collected, shutdown_request → Blue
│
├─ Phase 3: RED RE-ATTACK (1 teammate per module)
│  └── red-reattacker-N ── TaskUpdate: DEFEATED/BYPASSED/INCOMPLETE
│  └── shutdown_request → re-attackers
│
├─ RELEASE: SAFE / BLOCK
└─ TeamDelete

---

<CRITICAL_EXECUTION_REQUIREMENT>

STEP -1 — Inherit Prior Findings: If <EXODIA_FINDINGS_CONTEXT> tag exists in session context, read .eight-gates/artifacts/findings.json. Inject findings into Red Team prompts as attack surface hints. Do NOT give to Blue — they defend blind.

THIS IS AN ADVERSARIAL EXERCISE.

STEP 0 — Create Team: TeamCreate: team_name = "red-blue-review", description = "Adversarial review: $0"

STEP 1 — Red Attack Phase: Spawn 3 Red attackers as teammates (ALL in ONE message): Task tool: team_name="red-blue-review", name="red-crash-hunter", subagent_type="general-purpose", model="opus" Task tool: team_name="red-blue-review", name="red-security-attacker", subagent_type="general-purpose", model="opus" Task tool: team_name="red-blue-review", name="red-api-breaker", subagent_type="general-purpose", model="opus"