delay-analysis

Delay Analysis

Overview

Analyze construction schedule delays for project recovery and claims. Perform time impact analysis (TIA), identify concurrent delays, calculate delay damages, and prepare documentation for dispute resolution.

"Proper delay analysis is essential for fair resolution of construction disputes" — DDC Community

Delay Analysis Methods

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                    DELAY ANALYSIS METHODS                        │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                                                                  │
│  As-Planned vs As-Built    │    Time Impact Analysis (TIA)      │
│  ─────────────────────     │    ────────────────────────────    │
│  Compare original to       │    Insert delay events into        │
│  actual schedule           │    schedule to measure impact      │
│                            │                                     │
│  Windows Analysis          │    Collapsed As-Built              │
│  ────────────────          │    ─────────────────               │
│  Divide project into       │    Remove delays from as-built     │
│  time periods              │    to find "but-for" completion    │
│                                                                  │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Technical Implementation

from dataclasses import dataclass, field
from typing import List, Dict, Optional, Tuple
from datetime import datetime, timedelta
from enum import Enum
from collections import defaultdict

class DelayType(Enum):
    EXCUSABLE_COMPENSABLE = "excusable_compensable"      # Owner caused - time + money
    EXCUSABLE_NON_COMPENSABLE = "excusable_non_compensable"  # Neither party - time only
    NON_EXCUSABLE = "non_excusable"                      # Contractor caused - no relief
    CONCURRENT = "concurrent"                            # Both parties - complex

class DelayCause(Enum):
    OWNER_CHANGE = "owner_change"
    LATE_INFORMATION = "late_information"
    DIFFERING_CONDITIONS = "differing_conditions"
    PERMIT_DELAY = "permit_delay"
    WEATHER = "weather"
    LABOR_SHORTAGE = "labor_shortage"
    MATERIAL_DELAY = "material_delay"
    SUBCONTRACTOR = "subcontractor"
    COORDINATION = "coordination"
    ACCESS = "access"
    FORCE_MAJEURE = "force_majeure"

@dataclass
class DelayEvent:
    id: str
    description: str
    cause: DelayCause
    delay_type: DelayType
    start_date: datetime
    end_date: datetime
    affected_activities: List[str]
    responsible_party: str
    documented: bool = True
    supporting_docs: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)
    calculated_impact: int = 0  # days
    concurrent_with: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)

@dataclass
class ScheduleVersion:
    version_id: str
    version_type: str  # baseline, update, as-built
    data_date: datetime
    completion_date: datetime
    activities: Dict[str, Dict]  # activity_id -> {start, finish, duration}

@dataclass
class WindowPeriod:
    window_id: str
    start_date: datetime
    end_date: datetime
    planned_progress: float
    actual_progress: float
    delay_days: int
    delay_events: List[str]
    responsible_parties: Dict[str, int]  # party -> delay days

@dataclass
class DelayAnalysisReport:
    project_name: str
    analysis_date: datetime
    original_completion: datetime
    actual_completion: datetime
    total_delay: int
    excusable_delay: int
    non_excusable_delay: int
    concurrent_delay: int
    delay_events: List[DelayEvent]
    delay_by_cause: Dict[str, int]
    delay_by_party: Dict[str, int]
    recommended_extension: int
    potential_damages: float

class DelayAnalyzer:
    """Analyze construction schedule delays."""

    # Daily delay costs by project size
    DEFAULT_DAILY_COSTS = {
        "small": 5000,      # < $10M
        "medium": 15000,    # $10M - $50M
        "large": 40000,     # $50M - $200M
        "mega": 100000      # > $200M
    }

    def __init__(self, project_name: str, contract_completion: datetime):
        self.project_name = project_name
        self.contract_completion = contract_completion
        self.delay_events: Dict[str, DelayEvent] = {}
        self.schedule_versions: Dict[str, ScheduleVersion] = {}
        self.window_periods: List[WindowPeriod] = []
        self.daily_cost = self.DEFAULT_DAILY_COSTS["medium"]

    def set_daily_delay_cost(self, cost: float):
        """Set daily delay cost for damages calculation."""
        self.daily_cost = cost

    def add_schedule_version(self, version_id: str, version_type: str,
                            data_date: datetime, completion_date: datetime,
                            activities: Dict[str, Dict]) -> ScheduleVersion:
        """Add schedule version for analysis."""
        version = ScheduleVersion(
            version_id=version_id,
            version_type=version_type,
            data_date=data_date,
            completion_date=completion_date,
            activities=activities
        )
        self.schedule_versions[version_id] = version
        return version

    def add_delay_event(self, id: str, description: str,
                       cause: DelayCause, delay_type: DelayType,
                       start_date: datetime, end_date: datetime,
                       affected_activities: List[str],
                       responsible_party: str,
                       supporting_docs: List[str] = None) -> DelayEvent:
        """Add delay event for analysis."""
        event = DelayEvent(
            id=id,
            description=description,
            cause=cause,
            delay_type=delay_type,
            start_date=start_date,
            end_date=end_date,
            affected_activities=affected_activities,
            responsible_party=responsible_party,
            supporting_docs=supporting_docs or []
        )
        self.delay_events[id] = event
        return event

    def perform_as_planned_vs_as_built(self) -> Dict:
        """Perform As-Planned vs As-Built analysis."""
        baseline = self.schedule_versions.get("baseline")
        as_built = self.schedule_versions.get("as_built")

        if not baseline or not as_built:
            raise ValueError("Need baseline and as-built schedules")

        total_delay = (as_built.completion_date - baseline.completion_date).days

        # Analyze each activity
        activity_delays = []
        for act_id, baseline_act in baseline.activities.items():
            if act_id in as_built.activities:
                as_built_act = as_built.activities[act_id]

                baseline_finish = baseline_act['finish']
                actual_finish = as_built_act['finish']

                if isinstance(baseline_finish, str):
                    baseline_finish = datetime.fromisoformat(baseline_finish)
                if isinstance(actual_finish, str):
                    actual_finish = datetime.fromisoformat(actual_finish)

                delay = (actual_finish - baseline_finish).days

                if delay > 0:
                    activity_delays.append({
                        'activity_id': act_id,
                        'planned_finish': baseline_finish,
                        'actual_finish': actual_finish,
                        'delay_days': delay
                    })

        return {
            'method': 'As-Planned vs As-Built',
            'baseline_completion': baseline.completion_date,
            'actual_completion': as_built.completion_date,
            'total_delay': total_delay,
            'activity_delays': sorted(activity_delays, key=lambda x: -x['delay_days'])
        }

    def perform_time_impact_analysis(self, delay_event_id: str) -> Dict:
        """Perform Time Impact Analysis for specific delay event."""
        if delay_event_id not in self.delay_events:
            raise ValueError(f"Delay event {delay_event_id} not found")

        event = self.delay_events[delay_event_id]

        # Find schedule version just before delay
        pre_delay_schedule = None
        for version in sorted(self.schedule_versions.values(),
                            key=lambda v: v.data_date, reverse=True):
            if version.data_date < event.start_date:
                pre_delay_schedule = version
                break

        if not pre_delay_schedule:
            pre_delay_schedule = self.schedule_versions.get("baseline")

        if not pre_delay_schedule:
            raise ValueError("No pre-delay schedule found")

        # Calculate impact
        original_completion = pre_delay_schedule.completion_date
        delay_duration = (event.end_date - event.start_date).days

        # Check if delay is on critical path
        critical_impact = False
        for act_id in event.affected_activities:
            if act_id in pre_delay_schedule.activities:
                act = pre_delay_schedule.activities[act_id]
                if act.get('is_critical', False):
                    critical_impact = True
                    break

        if critical_impact:
            impact_days = delay_duration
            new_completion = original_completion + timedelta(days=delay_duration)
        else:
            # Need to check float
            impact_days = max(0, delay_duration - 5)  # Simplified - assume 5 days float
            new_completion = original_completion + timedelta(days=impact_days)

        event.calculated_impact = impact_days

        return {
            'method': 'Time Impact Analysis',
            'delay_event': event.id,
            'delay_description': event.description,
            'delay_duration': delay_duration,
            'critical_path_impact': critical_impact,
            'schedule_impact_days': impact_days,
            'original_completion': original_completion,
            'impacted_completion': new_completion,
            'delay_type': event.delay_type.value,
            'responsible_party': event.responsible_party
        }

    def identify_concurrent_delays(self) -> List[Tuple[str, str, int]]:
        """Identify concurrent delay events."""
        concurrent = []

        events = list(self.delay_events.values())
        for i, event1 in enumerate(events):
            for event2 in events[i+1:]:
                # Check for overlap
                overlap_start = max(event1.start_date, event2.start_date)
                overlap_end = min(event1.end_date, event2.end_date)

                if overlap_start < overlap_end:
                    overlap_days = (overlap_end - overlap_start).days
                    concurrent.append((event1.id, event2.id, overlap_days))

                    event1.concurrent_with.append(event2.id)
                    event2.concurrent_with.append(event1.id)

        return concurrent

    def perform_windows_analysis(self, window_days: int = 30) -> List[WindowPeriod]:
        """Perform windows analysis by dividing project into periods."""
        baseline = self.schedule_versions.get("baseline")
        as_built = self.schedule_versions.get("as_built")

        if not baseline or not as_built:
            raise ValueError("Need baseline and as-built schedules")

        windows = []
        current_start = baseline.data_date
        window_num = 1

        while current_start < as_built.completion_date:
            window_end = min(
                current_start + timedelta(days=window_days),
                as_built.completion_date
            )

            # Find delay events in this window
            window_events = [
                e.id for e in self.delay_events.values()
                if e.start_date < window_end and e.end_date > current_start
            ]

            # Calculate delay by party
            party_delays = defaultdict(int)
            for event_id in window_events:
                event = self.delay_events[event_id]
                overlap_start = max(event.start_date, current_start)
                overlap_end = min(event.end_date, window_end)
                days = (overlap_end - overlap_start).days
                party_delays[event.responsible_party] += days

            window = WindowPeriod(
                window_id=f"W{window_num:02d}",
                start_date=current_start,
                end_date=window_end,
                planned_progress=0.0,  # Would calculate from schedule
                actual_progress=0.0,
                delay_days=sum(party_delays.values()),
                delay_events=window_events,
                responsible_parties=dict(party_delays)
            )
            windows.append(window)

            current_start = window_end
            window_num += 1

        self.window_periods = windows
        return windows

    def calculate_delay_damages(self) -> Dict:
        """Calculate potential delay damages."""
        # Summarize delays by type
        excusable_compensable = 0
        excusable_non_compensable = 0
        non_excusable = 0

        for event in self.delay_events.values():
            impact = event.calculated_impact or (event.end_date - event.start_date).days

            # Adjust for concurrency
            if event.concurrent_with:
                impact = impact // 2  # Simplified concurrency handling

            if event.delay_type == DelayType.EXCUSABLE_COMPENSABLE:
                excusable_compensable += impact
            elif event.delay_type == DelayType.EXCUSABLE_NON_COMPENSABLE:
                excusable_non_compensable += impact
            elif event.delay_type == DelayType.NON_EXCUSABLE:
                non_excusable += impact

        # Calculate damages
        contractor_damages = excusable_compensable * self.daily_cost
        owner_ld = non_excusable * self.daily_cost

        return {
            'excusable_compensable_days': excusable_compensable,
            'excusable_non_compensable_days': excusable_non_compensable,
            'non_excusable_days': non_excusable,
            'recommended_time_extension': excusable_compensable + excusable_non_compensable,
            'contractor_delay_damages': contractor_damages,
            'owner_liquidated_damages': owner_ld,
            'daily_rate_used': self.daily_cost
        }

    def generate_analysis_report(self, actual_completion: datetime) -> DelayAnalysisReport:
        """Generate comprehensive delay analysis report."""
        total_delay = (actual_completion - self.contract_completion).days

        # Categorize delays
        delay_by_cause = defaultdict(int)
        delay_by_party = defaultdict(int)
        excusable = 0
        non_excusable = 0
        concurrent = 0

        for event in self.delay_events.values():
            impact = event.calculated_impact or (event.end_date - event.start_date).days

            delay_by_cause[event.cause.value] += impact
            delay_by_party[event.responsible_party] += impact

            if event.concurrent_with:
                concurrent += impact // 2
            elif event.delay_type in [DelayType.EXCUSABLE_COMPENSABLE,
                                      DelayType.EXCUSABLE_NON_COMPENSABLE]:
                excusable += impact
            else:
                non_excusable += impact

        damages = self.calculate_delay_damages()

        return DelayAnalysisReport(
            project_name=self.project_name,
            analysis_date=datetime.now(),
            original_completion=self.contract_completion,
            actual_completion=actual_completion,
            total_delay=total_delay,
            excusable_delay=excusable,
            non_excusable_delay=non_excusable,
            concurrent_delay=concurrent,
            delay_events=list(self.delay_events.values()),
            delay_by_cause=dict(delay_by_cause),
            delay_by_party=dict(delay_by_party),
            recommended_extension=damages['recommended_time_extension'],
            potential_damages=damages['contractor_delay_damages']
        )

    def generate_report_markdown(self, report: DelayAnalysisReport) -> str:
        """Generate markdown report."""
        lines = [
            "# Delay Analysis Report",
            "",
            f"**Project:** {report.project_name}",
            f"**Analysis Date:** {report.analysis_date.strftime('%Y-%m-%d')}",
            "",
            "## Schedule Summary",
            "",
            f"| Milestone | Date |",
            f"|-----------|------|",
            f"| Contract Completion | {report.original_completion.strftime('%Y-%m-%d')} |",
            f"| Actual Completion | {report.actual_completion.strftime('%Y-%m-%d')} |",
            f"| **Total Delay** | **{report.total_delay} days** |",
            "",
            "## Delay Classification",
            "",
            f"| Category | Days |",
            f"|----------|------|",
            f"| Excusable Delay | {report.excusable_delay} |",
            f"| Non-Excusable Delay | {report.non_excusable_delay} |",
            f"| Concurrent Delay | {report.concurrent_delay} |",
            "",
            "## Delay by Cause",
            ""
        ]

        for cause, days in sorted(report.delay_by_cause.items(), key=lambda x: -x[1]):
            lines.append(f"- **{cause}**: {days} days")

        lines.extend([
            "",
            "## Delay by Responsible Party",
            ""
        ])

        for party, days in sorted(report.delay_by_party.items(), key=lambda x: -x[1]):
            lines.append(f"- **{party}**: {days} days")

        lines.extend([
            "",
            "## Recommendations",
            "",
            f"- **Recommended Time Extension:** {report.recommended_extension} days",
            f"- **Potential Delay Damages:** ${report.potential_damages:,.0f}",
            ""
        ])

        return "\n".join(lines)