dual-ai-paper-coach: Skill for Claude Code

Skill: codex-review

何时使用

• 用户说："让 Codex 看看"、"独立审稿"、"找盲区"、"挑刺"、"换个 AI 审一下"
• 用户跑 /codex-review slash command
• 用户在 /iterate 流程中需要新一轮审稿

核心原则（死规则）

你（Claude）从不审这份稿子。审稿是 Codex 的工作。你的角色是：

1. 触发 Codex 子进程
2. 等它完成
3. 读它写的 review 文件
4. 把内容传递给用户

如果你"自己"审，整个项目的"独立审稿"价值就毁了。

输出语言策略：发给 Codex 的 prompt 体保持英文（保证审稿报告与英文论文一致 + /iterate 命令依赖固定的英文措辞模式做替换）。中文 SKILL 说明只供人类阅读，不 影响 AI 输出。

工作流

步骤 1：环境检查

codex --version

如果失败（codex 未安装）→ 提示用户：

未检测到 Codex CLI。安装：
npm install -g @openai/codex
codex login    # 用 ChatGPT Plus/Pro 账号

如果 codex login 报未认证 → 提示用户登录。

步骤 2：定位轮次号

读 my-paper/review_round_*.md，找最大 N，本次为 N+1。

第一次审稿 → N=1。

步骤 3：触发 Codex

Bash / zsh（macOS / Linux / WSL，用反斜线续行）：

ROUND=<N+1>
codex exec --skip-git-repo-check --sandbox workspace-write \
  -c 'model_reasoning_effort="xhigh"' \
  "Read AGENTS.md, prompts/reviewer_system.md, prompts/review_paper.md, my-paper/draft.md, and if present my-paper/data/analysis_results.json. Replace {manuscript} in review_paper.md with the contents of draft.md. If analysis_results.json is present, verify every quantitative manuscript claim against it and flag any mismatch or unverifiable number as a Critical Issue. If it is absent, state that numerical verification was unavailable. Produce a structured peer review per the format in reviewer_system.md. Write to my-paper/review_round_${ROUND}.md. Do not modify any other files."

PowerShell（Windows，用反引号续行——PowerShell 不认 \）：

$ROUND = <N+1>
codex exec --skip-git-repo-check --sandbox workspace-write `
  -c 'model_reasoning_effort="xhigh"' `
  "Read AGENTS.md, prompts/reviewer_system.md, prompts/review_paper.md, my-paper/draft.md, and if present my-paper/data/analysis_results.json. Replace {manuscript} in review_paper.md with the contents of draft.md. If analysis_results.json is present, verify every quantitative manuscript claim against it and flag any mismatch or unverifiable number as a Critical Issue. If it is absent, state that numerical verification was unavailable. Produce a structured peer review per the format in reviewer_system.md. Write to my-paper/review_round_$ROUND.md. Do not modify any other files."