coarse-classify

/coarse-classify — Classify, Calibrate, Contribute, Literature

Usage: /coarse-classify <slug>

Argument ($ARGUMENTS) is the paper slug (e.g. my-paper). All paths are relative to the workspace root d:/Dropbox/Research/Coarse Reviewer/.

Path setup

• EXTRACTED = .coarse_cache/<slug>_extracted.md
• SECTIONS_JSON = .coarse_cache/<slug>_sections.json
• CLASSIFICATION = .coarse_cache/<slug>_classification.json
• CALIBRATION = .coarse_cache/<slug>_calibration.json
• CONTRIBUTION = .coarse_cache/<slug>_contribution.json
• LITERATURE = .coarse_cache/<slug>_literature.txt

Read SECTIONS_JSON and the first 2000 chars of EXTRACTED before starting.

---

Step 3 — Classify

Determine:

• title: exact paper title from the first page
• domain: e.g. social_sciences/economics, computer_science/machine_learning, statistics/causal_inference, natural_sciences/biology
• taxonomy: e.g. academic/research_paper, academic/review_paper, academic/working_paper
• abstract: the paper's abstract text
• math_sections: list of section indices (0-based) whose math_content should be true. A section needs math verification if it contains ANY of: proofs (formal or informal), theorem/lemma/proposition/corollary statements with arguments, formal definitions or assumptions, algebraic manipulations, estimator definitions, asymptotic expressions.

Save to CLASSIFICATION using the Write tool:

{
  "title": "...",
  "domain": "...",
  "taxonomy": "...",
  "abstract": "...",
  "math_sections": [0, 2, 4]
}

---

Step 4 — Domain Calibration

Using the paper's title, domain, abstract, and section list, produce a domain-specific review calibration.

You are an expert academic reviewer. For each field below, provide 3-5 concise items tailored to this paper's specific domain and methodology:

1. methodology_concerns: The key methodological concerns for this type of paper
2. assumption_red_flags: Assumptions that commonly fail in this domain
3. what_not_to_check: What is irrelevant for this paper type
4. evaluation_standards: What a top-tier journal in this field expects