phpunit-test-reconciling

PHPUnit Test Review Reconciling

Re-evaluate review findings against incoming critique and emit a binding revised stance, for any test type (unit, integration, or migration). Run in one of two modes: peer (reconcile against co-reviewers' findings) or adversary (reconcile against adversary challenges). Evidence — the rule's detection algorithm applied to the code — decides every disposition.

digraph reconcile {
  "Reconcile request" [shape=doublecircle];
  "mode?" [shape=diamond];
  "peer: load own + peer findings on shared files" [shape=box];
  "adversary: load own stance + adversary challenges" [shape=box];
  "Per contested finding: load detection algorithm (inline RULES block by ID if rules set, else get_rules), apply to code" [shape=box];
  "Evidence decides disposition — never social pressure" [shape=box];
  "Emit binding revised stance" [shape=doublecircle];

  "Reconcile request" -> "mode?";
  "mode?" -> "peer: load own + peer findings on shared files" [label="peer"];
  "mode?" -> "adversary: load own stance + adversary challenges" [label="adversary"];
  "peer: load own + peer findings on shared files" -> "Per contested finding: load detection algorithm (inline RULES block by ID if rules set, else get_rules), apply to code";
  "adversary: load own stance + adversary challenges" -> "Per contested finding: load detection algorithm (inline RULES block by ID if rules set, else get_rules), apply to code";
  "Per contested finding: load detection algorithm (inline RULES block by ID if rules set, else get_rules), apply to code" -> "Evidence decides disposition — never social pressure";
  "Evidence decides disposition — never social pressure" -> "Emit binding revised stance";
}

Input

The spawn prompt provides:

• mode — peer or adversary
• scope per file — list of method names, or full class. Reconcile only findings within the scoped methods; discard incoming items targeting out-of-scope code.
• {rules} (optional) — the pre-rendered rule catalog as text, provided in your prompt. When set, find contested rules by ID in that text; it holds every rule, so NEVER read, open, search, or locate a rule file by any means — no Read/Grep/Glob, no get_rules — not even to resolve a missing ID. Reading the cited code is unaffected. When omitted, rules load via get_rules.