peer-review skills

36 tagged peer-review, measured the same way as everything else here.

Browse within: academic-paper-review 19ai-peer-review 19research-paper 19research-tool 19academic-writing 13ai-generated-content 12ai-scientist 12autoresearch 12forensics 12llm-agents 12academic 10hypothesis 9ai-research 6literature-review 5

wanshuiyin/Anti-Autoresearch

Skill Claude Code

Audit whether a paper's baseline comparisons are COMPLETE, FAIR, and SIGNIFICANT: a required recent SOTA baseline is missing while 'best/SOTA' is claimed (HP-MISSING-BASELINE); a baseline is undertuned / given less compute-tuning-data, run at a mismatched config, or the equal-budget ablation-as-baseline is absent…

not rated 164 +4 11d ago A SkillSpector: warn 310 tokens original MIT

amirkiarafiei/open-scholar-peer

Skill Claude CodeCodex

Open ScholarPeer Literature Review & Expansion Agent — performs External Context retrieval via the dynamic-web search strategy. Activate this persona when the user invokes /2-osp-literature. Runs up to three distinct rounds — the user chooses how many (sub-domain anchor, method anchor, temporal expansion) to construct…

not rated 48 +2 changed 23d ago A SkillSpector: pass 72 tokens original MIT

paper-sprint-review

03

RichradsY/PaperSprint

Skill Codex

PaperSprint is a Scrum-inspired academic paper agent workflow for conference or journal drafts. Use when Codex needs to clarify paper direction, estimate likely sprint count, set sprint goals and focus areas, assess venue fit, organize reviewer or editor lenses, convert critique into a prioritized revision backlog…

not rated 39 7mo ago A 94 tokens original MIT

LLM Council

04

shuntacurosu/llm_council_skill

Skill Claude CodeCodex

Orchestrate multiple LLMs as a council, generating collective intelligence through peer review and chairman synthesis.

not rated 37 10mo ago A 24 tokens

paper-workshop

05

tjhavranek/paper-workshop

Skill Claude CodeCodex

CRUCIBLE: a Claude-only adversarial expert workshop that stress-tests a scientific paper and then, opt-in, rebuilds it. ACT I (TRIBUNAL): from the paper PDF (plus a few public cited works it fetches), a topic-adapted fleet of expert referee subagents (every contested claim argued from at least two COMPETING…

not rated 11 2mo ago A 524 tokens

expert-review-panel

06

tianmind-studio/expert-review-panel

Skill Claude CodeCodex

A structured process for getting several role-specific reviewers to examine a paper, business plan, presentation, code, or other submission before it is sent out.

not rated 2 4mo ago A 254 tokens original MIT

omnirebuttal

07

Iayce/omnirebuttal

Skill Claude CodeCodex

Unified author-response skill for all peer-review rebuttal formats: CV one-page PDF (CVPR/ICCV/ECCV), OpenReview threaded discussion (NeurIPS/ICLR/ACM MM), per-review character limits (ICML/KDD), Nature/journal point-by-point revision letters, and ARR/TMLR rolling revision. Routes by venue artifact family after shared…

not rated 2 4mo ago A 163 tokens original MIT

At most 3 mods per repository are shown here, and a mod shipped inside a plugin is left to that plugin's page — the rest are on their repository pages: